Why didn’t you convert your site to WordPress? You said you had to import it from Mediawiki to WordPress already.
I had this conversation with my wife, too.
WordPress is awesome at being a dynamic website. To be a static ‘wiki’ style website, it sucks. It’s not meant to be static like that. It’s not intended to be static. Even if you turn off comments on your site, you mean for WordPress to generate index pages and categories and the like.
With WordPress, all that work is done on the server. When you visit a page, it’s generated for the first time. I may have a cache that lets reader number 2 see that page, but always the page, the HTML, is being dynamically built on-demand. MediaWiki works the same way. In contrast, Jekyll is dynamically built on my laptop and deployed as an in-situ static site. Each HTML page is a real HTML page on the server. No extra work has to happen. It’s small, it’s light, and it’s fast, because all that processing was done by me on my laptop before putting it on the server.
And that actually illustrates the problem with WordPress, and why we struggle with things like Varnish and nginx and caching. We want our sites to do more and be faster. We need flexibility and posting to Twitter and dynamic page generation when we make an edit, because we’re constantly making changes.
Except I didn’t. I don’t. Not the particular site I was working on, anyway. The site has about 1000 pages (probably closer to 600 once I decided not to import some of the things) and they’re pretty static. At most I updated them once a week for half the year. WordPress would be overkill. Hell, the Wiki was overkill and the only reason I kept using it was technological debt. I didn’t want to add to the debt. I didn’t want to make things even weirder and harder to use. I didn’t want to put a site more at risk with software I didn’t want to upkeep (MediaWiki, not WordPress).
So it was clearly time to dig myself out with a little sweat equity and decide what I really wanted. I made a list of what I needed, what I wanted, and what I could live without. When I did that, Jekyll started looking more and more like a viable option. I would have spent as much time removing the aspects of WordPress I don’t need as I would have learning a new theme system and language.
Also in the end I didn’t use the WordPress import. I manually copy/pasted content. The content was what I wanted, and I needed it text only, and MediaWiki made that damn hard to get at. Of course the Jekyll exporter for WordPress was pretty freaking cool. If I was pure WordPress to Jekyll, I’d be fine. I guess there just aren’t a lot of people doing MediaWiki exports.
